Character(s) you would want to be exclusive to the GN

[Susannah Dean]

Shiva, as many others have mentioned...just thinking about how it can be convincingly pulled off just frightens me lol.

[Will]

Negan is an obvious straight forward choice as I have no faith in the show being able to pull him off, so I'd want Negan to be a GN exclusive.

Shiva I'd like to see remain a GN exclusive as well as again I don't think the show would do justice to it. They'll probably make a CGI tiger and then kill it off within a couple of episodes due to costs.

[ElJacko]

Hmm...how about all of them?

[Frankenstein]

Jessie Anderson.

[Nomis210]

Ezekiel and the entire Kingdom hands fucking down.

[blackjack]

I have to admit, although I am unbelievably excited about Negan's arrival, I am also nervous about it. After seeing how much they changed the Governor and I feel they really watered down Abraham, I'm afraid they won't stay anywhere near true to the character. Negan without "Fuck," is workable, but he has to be nasty, vulgar, funny, and BRUTAL. However, I'm ecstatic about him being in the show. The one I'd have liked them to have kept strictly to the comics was Gabriel, but that boat has sailed.

[Manasicaroltwd]

Ezekiel and Shiva (maybe whole Kingdom arc)
I can't think of them pulling that out without messing everything lol

[Joan Holloway]

Ezekiel should be left out
The entire whisperers arc isn't working for me, so I can only imagine how boring it would be on the show.
Magna and her crew are pointless too.

[Ívarr inn Beinlausi]

Lydia/Alpha and the freaks, awful story

[blackjack]

The Whisperers. I want the show to end shortly after All Out War. Alternatively, they can create a villain that's exclusive to the show. I don't even like them in the comics and can't wait for their story to get over with. As much as I love her in the comics, Shiva along with Ezekiel wouldn't transfer over very well. It would be too comedic and would hurt The Walking Dead as far as ratings go, I'd assume. It's fun in the comics, but would lower the quality of the show.